Wednesday, March 31, 2010

Boston 2010


on our first night, we ate at the daily catch in the north end


i had linguine and clams while lynn had black pasta (squid ink) and fresh calamari (not pictured because we ate it already)


mike's pastry shop across the street


lynn's lobster roll


a very busy saturday lunch at the quincy market


at the quincy market


from quincy market


from quincy market



the old state house


lynn and i saw a good play at the huntington (BU) theatre


the inside of the huntington


lynn and anh touching a horseshoe crab at the new england aquarium.


flower shop in beacon hill, near the flat of the hill


i love the way roots of stately trees and beacon hill's famed red brick sidewalks co-exist.


the clock tower, the night we arrived. this view is from close to our hotel, across the former big dig.



we dim summed here


frying cart for our lo bak goh
jordan and simone chin-glish and english grammar:

1) bin goh first hai win (whoever is first is wins)

2) I (or I'm) is a bad guy (replace 'bad guy' with just about anything)

... and simone's current favourite phrase: ley zhong yi gno ma? (do you like me?)

Monday, March 15, 2010

playing '20 (or as many as needed) questions' in the car:

me: is it a place?

jordan: yes

simone: hai m hai montreal?

jordan: m hai

simone: hai m hai cauliflower?

jordan: m hai

simone: hai m hai montreal?

jordan (frustrated): m haiiii-uh...
A few weeks ago during dinner at fellowship, we had a random discussion about China, which led us in many directions. Recently I couldn't sleep and the topic resurfaced in my mind.

I'd like to use an example that C-moe gave us as a springboard. Workers at a factory in China, shut-down through western pressures, were on strike to re-open the factory, desperately wanting to work. While I believe that their cause is legitimate- the need and desire to work- there are not enough facts to suggest that the factory shouldn't be closed. If it was unsustainable, and/or unsafe and/or an abusive environment, that should be reason enough.

I suspect that the bosses of that factory explained it this way to their workers: the West is meddling in our ways, and by giving you all dust masks or safety helmets, and by installing an expensive air filter on our smokestack, we can no longer give competitive prices, so we have lost our market share and are forced to close. They would probably also evoke the sentiment that the western politicians are not motivated by benevolence, but by protectionist economics (jobs of lazy american workers with too many benefits).

But motives being whatever they are, I mentioned three key ideas that believe are absolute:

  1. Sustainability (prevention of global environmental degradation)

  2. Safety (prevention of life-threatening danger) and

  3. Human Rights (prevention of abusiveness).

Many believe that these are relative concepts, but I think that they are in fact universal. It is easy to see that pollution and waste, and asthma and head injuries are the same on either side of the ocean, but what about mistreatment, unfair pay, and other abuses? I believe that they are also, but sometimes we use the argument of culture to justify our loose definition of abuse. Perhaps, for example, the concept of authority in chinese culture permits verbal and even sexual abuse. A boss can do whatever he wants to do, and recourse for the abused is limited, so that's life.

But, assuming we believe that evil is evil, here and there, what should we do about it?

First we must recognize that we have a privileged perspective, and by this, I don't mean biased. We cannot expect the migrant workers of the closed factory to make long-term, broad-based, informed decisions. They seek primarily to support their families, and their cares are limited to their immediate concerns. They don't care that the chemicals they send into the atmosphere have global consequences. They don't even care if the risks to personal safety and health are elevated, if the risks are just part of the job that feeds their children. And we shouldn't expect them to care beyond that!

The beef industry in Chicago at the turn of the century was a trust, that is, a monopoly of companies that controlled prices. They were also excessively abusive of their employees and made them work in highly unsanitary and unsafe conditions. The journalist Upton Sinclair described the hellish working conditions of the meatpackers in his novel “The Jungle.” When the novel came to the attention of Theodore Rooselvelt, there was an immediate inquiry as to how much of Sinclair's work was true. The president's people came back to tell him that it was actually a hundred times worse! The result was health legislation, the formation of the Food and Drug Administration, and sweeping reforms to safety and work conditions.

What I want to point out is that it was not the meatpackers themselves, who could not see how, or even if they should organize their labour, but a muckracking journalist who brought about the changes that were needed. Sinclair's priviledged perspective made him feel responsible for a certain measure of action.

In fact, history is full of intervention. Of course, some are born of dubiously motivated foreign policy, and some are quite unsuccessful, even making things worse. But without American intervention after the wars with the Marshall plan, the economies of Europe may have never recovered so quickly. Without foreign agitation, some historians argue that the Berlin Wall would not have fallen. Without the embargoes of South Africa, and without the numerous political pressures and rock concerts, apartheid could still be a reality today. Canadian and other UN peacekeepers do, in fact, keep the peace.

Remember the relatively recent threat of holes in the ozone layer? Well, we don't hear much about it anymore because we are on the road to recovery (still a ways to go, but most scientists are hopeful). How? Through enforceable policy (banning CFCs, etc) and international cooperation/pressure (the Montreal protocol) over the past 20 years.

I wonder if part of the reason the students of Tiananmen Square held their ground was because they knew western media and western support would vindicate them. One has to ask what China would do to Taiwan if America did not have a naval base nearby, or to Tibet, if the Dalai Lama didn't have widespread western support. Again, let's not argue motives, but results. Intervention, in its various forms and to various degrees, is called for, and can matter.

So if we are to intervene, how should we do it?

First, we can comment, suggest, and debate amongst ourselves. We can boycott when our conscience so dictates. We can make small decisions and be party to grassroots movements. But laissez-faire economics, attitudes, or policies are not the solution.

The next few paragraphs concentrate on urbanity and environment, and are not without reason. I'm not a macroeconomist or a politician, so my arguments about policy strategies carry little weight. My interests lie in the fields of urban planning and architecture, and the contribution of the built environment to the betterment of society in general. I expect that a engineers I work with care about these things too, and many of them do. I have an opinion about health care, but I'm not a doctor. I expect that doctors care enough to be vested somewhat in health care reform. I expect businessmen and financial people to care about business ethics and have informed ideas on how to solve the current crisis. In short, I suggest that we do not all have the energy or resources to care about all topics, but there is no profession (or aspect of civil society) that does not need reform. I can do little to help farmers change agriculture, or teachers change schools, but I can and should comment on the direction of design on the urban scale.

China is repeating our mistakes, or has been perhaps until recently. One major example would be the massive environmental errors that the western world would not (or should not) make again. To be sure, there are still problems with pollution in the West, but the West has been spending the last century cleaning up and learning from its industrial revolution. Now another, much bigger, industrial revolution is occurring on the other side of the world, its impact floating back over the ocean. This would have been avoidable if China and other Asian tiger countries looked to the future of western development policy, or if they developed their own progressive policy, instead of looking to past western models that were short-sighted.

Another mistake would be in the area of transportation. As the West tries to move away from a car-centric culture, China continues to make cars and build new infrastructure for them. (Worse still is that their cars have no air bags or safety belts and I'm certain that the fatality rates are much higher than whatever government statistics would tell). Instead, shouldn't Chinese cities model their growth on the highly successful mass transit systems of major South American cities like Bogota? There, progressive governments refuse to further alienate the population by promoting nonsensical car travel. Rather than look to Detroit, they looked to highly sophisticated cities in Europe where mass transit was exceptionally designed and implemented. Instead of building cheap and unsafe cars, they did something technologically and socially advanced that will surely pay economic dividends.

Many will complain that it is unfair to ask China (and India) not to make cars, or not to seek the so-called luxuries of western life and the former American Dream, but that is precisely what is needed to build a long-term, sustainable, and truly progressive economy. The production of cars is an artificial economic stimulus, and efforts to promote the industry are made at the expense of better and more sustainable (economically and environmentally) alternatives.

Government sanctioned films such as Hero (Ying-Xiong) encourage the ancient virtue of selflessness and sacrifice for the greater good. But there is nothing remotely selfless or beneficial for the greater community in owning a car, much less a fancy one. Such is the dichotomy that China faces today. There are other examples of mutually exclusive policies/ideologies. On one hand, there is a great push to promote health and general well-being through exercise in city parks, but on the other hand, smog from industry and traffic forces people indoors and behind masks.

The American Dream used to be something like the following: big home in the suburbs, white picket fence, barbecue on the patio, big front and back lawn, and two cars in a double garage. But that paradigm, thankfully, is shifting. It is common now for the upwardly-mobile, young, urban professionals to strive for denser, communal living, material goods of quality, not quantity, and a lifestyle of no automobile dependence. Most are not consciously giving up luxury, but are rather discovering that there are wiser ways to live and express luxury.

There is great evidence that China is following the old dream, the wasteful post-war, fossil-fuel dependent American dream. While other 'developing' cities looked to the future, and skipped the old dream, China's major cities are surrounded by acres of suburban sprawl, with single-detached, western-styled homes in gated communities. Many of the houses happen to be uninsulated concrete structures, which is lunacy, energy-wise. Is this really what China wants, or needs? It is the very model the western world is trying to shed.

Let's finally return to our original story. If the reasons are right, how then should a factory in China be shut down, or reformed? Well first, I think it has to be a wholesale change, applied to all competitors in the market, that is a matter of enforceable policy. If production follows acceptable safety and employee standards, and the price consequently increases, there will be market adjustments in terms of demand. But there cannot be a cheaper alternative based on differing standards, because all the producers would be under the same required standards. A factory boss cannot justifiably shut down a factory and blame it on the inability to unscrupulously violate safety, environmental, or human rights conditions.

The great capitalist industrialist J.P. Getty believed that international competitors were not to be feared by the enterprising american entrepreneur. He believed it was simply a call for further ingenuity and that those who complained about unfair competition from other countries were whiners. Of course, it is one thing to trim a little fat, and another to trim enough fat to compete against a chinese company that has no overhead of safety or no requirement for minimum wage! (He was commenting in the 1950s when the doors were just opening). Getty even welcomed the idea of unions, and understood the benefits that unions could bring to industry.

In the face of changing ideals, chinese companies will have to adjust to be competitive, but it should not be debilitating, especially if the rules are applied fairly across the industry in question. Getty's comment applies equally to the chinese leaders of industry! I am generally hopeful for China, because it has a wealth of potential to innovate on many fronts. I have no worries about its development in the tertiary economy (services/white collar), but its primary economies (resources, production, heavy industry, etc/blue collar), which will never go away, need to reform in serious ways in order to advance and even lead the world to a safer, sustainable, and dignified state.

I'm also hopeful because architecture, as with many art-forms, is a fair indicator of a culture's development. Less than 10 years ago, there were no notable chinese architects, that is, none that were were doing interesting work worth mentioning internationally. But today, many local architects are designing sensitive, progressive buildings that are celebrated in the critical international press. Their work stands in contrast to the many unrestrained alien forms deposited by Western architects over the past twenty years. (As you can imagine, this is the very brief version of this paragraph...)

I'd be more than pleased to hear your thoughts! (...and i hope i don't have a hard time getting a visa if ever i wanted to go back to china)


some references:

The Jungle, by Upton Sinclair

Confessions of an Economic Hitman, by John Perkins

Fast Food Nation, by Eric Schlosser

Suburban Nation, by Duanys and Plater-Zyberk

Design e2 - economies of environmental consciousness series

... and please Google the rest!