Optimistically Undefined: my current architectural self
Before I turned 18 I had in mind to settle my political stripes. As of today, I am staunchly non-partisan, not being able to find the party that is in line with my unique worldview… a condition that I'm sure is not unique. I have vacillated to some degree, and over the past decade, I have tempered a rather rigid orthodoxy, but the core of my morality has not changed.
I've been reading Obama lately and find great hope in his posture of optimism (and non-partisanship). I remember also a lecture by Libeskind. Well, actually, I remember nothing save a few money shots and one particular aside he made: he stated he was an optimist. Now, as I try to find my architectural voice, part of me can't help but be optimistic. I have always seen the glass as half-full.
So that's how I see myself: an optimistically undefined architect. But as with my politics, I'm not undefined because I can't pick sides. Maybe I'm undefined because I'm still rather young in the profession. Maybe I'm undefined because I like a lot of different 'styles' (for lack of a better word, or perhaps it is as Rybczynkski suggests: the mot juste). I like the starchitects' buildings, the scandinavian minimalists, the critical regionalists from all over, the contemporary modernists, and even the pre-modernists. To a theoretician or a contemporary critic, it may seem perverse to clump these disparate styles into the category of 'good architecture.' After all, Zaha Hadid and Frank Lloyd Wright (whom none of us studied, curiously) have little in common. Or do they? Perhaps what I'm after is that which is underlyingly undefined in the work of my pantheon of admired architects.
An essential part of architectural education is the critique, which, while serving as preparation for inevitable criticism of our work, is also supposed to instill in us a critical eye for the work of our contemporaries. Students are quick to point out the ugly buildings they see just about everywhere. Indeed, most buildings do fall short, but to dismiss them so summarily is not being a real, or even a good, critic. I was never fond of the quick analysis, and as part of my optimistic nature, tend to give the benefit of the doubt.
Some buildings are not great, and are only good because of circumstances beyond the architect's control. It is easy to say the architect did not fight enough for something when we are not that architect. A stubborn city, client, or other party may be such that an architect either capitulates a position (sells out) or quits (doesn't sell out). If he quits, it then begs the question whether the result would not be worse: a not-so-good, or even a bad architecture.
Even buildings that my friends would call bland or boring often have an architectural logic: I can see the decisions that created their form or details, and the product is often beyond mere engineering or program stuffing. Sure it's not great, and we probably would have done differently, and it is a lost opportunity. But sometimes we have to ask whether worse was more likely had that architect not taken the mandate.
I don't think it is healthy to always compare with better. This is what is wrong with most people's psychology, so I can't imagine it is good for architectural egos either. And like the proverbial 'Jones', sometimes the great buildings we idolize can have skeletons in their closets (they can be economically, technically, or pragmatically deficient, for which no amount of architectural extravagance can atone).
And it shouldn't keep us from admiring the caliber of work we intend on producing one day. One day all the pieces of the puzzle will be there: client, budget, city, etc. Even then, as my friends who work from the privileged design positions of starchitect's offices point out, there will be an exercise in give and take, and that never is it a blank slate.
As far as doing the best we can, i think it is a question of thoughtfulness. Again, a glimmer of thought in someone else's design is better than none at all, and i think 'none at all' is thankfully quite seldom the case. I think if I can truly say I spent the intellectual energy working a design to its best outcome, the result will be at least good, the thoughtfulness reflected to a great degree. Maybe thoughtfulness is that underlying undefinable characteristic of good architecture, regardless the style.
We should also be careful, for the sake of our own egos, to recognize the value of the work we've done so far. I wonder if Mies disowned the pre-modern house he did. And when Louis Kahn said that his next building would be his best, I don't think he meant that he considered that his past projects were not good. I've done some designs that i would rather not do again, but they are far from being regrets. If anything, the technical knowledge gained can only help realize the better stuff to come.
Being a graduate of this millennium, it would be hard for me to consider doing a Victorian home. Yet if the conditions were such that it was most appropriate to build one (and yes, contrary to most of my generation, I think such conditions can exist) I wonder if I would turn down the offer. You see, I am not without the arrogance to say that I could probably do a very good Victorian house, and that, if it is not me, there is a likelihood is great that it would be a poorly researched, badly-proportioned semblance of architecture.
In a sense, that arrogance leads me to the assumption that I am the determiner of good architecture. I have now the privilege of exercising that judgment, first on myself, then on others. I can now determine the degree to which I push a design, and the degree to which I fight for it. I will now be responsible for balancing ethical and economic imperatives with the quest for great architecture. I will also be the first judge of the end product.
But I will not its last or its only one. And when it is out there, standing against the backdrop of lesser and greater architecture, i hope it can be accorded some of that optimistic benefit of doubt i grant to others.













